My daughter (age 14) was invited to go to the cinema with her friend to see God’s Not Dead and Divergent. She’s been reading Divergent so she was excited about this opportunity as well as excited to hang out with her friend. I wasn’t surprised the other girls family planned to see God’s Not Dead since her mom is a practicing very religious Catholic. I told Kara it was a religious movie but she assured me she was fine with that.
It turned out the other girls family wasn’t going to the cinema, the girls were being dropped off, and once the first movie, God’s Not Dead, was over they didn’t have enough time to see Divergent. Kara was still happy to have had a school night to hang out with her friend and have fun.
The morning of the planned event I found a movie review from a little paper about the movie God’s Not Dead while waiting at the laundromat. It basically talked about how the movie made Atheist look like mean crazy people, Muslims look violent and Buddhist look pathetic. It talked about how the movie started off with the professor, played by Kevin Sorbo, who told all his students on the first day of class to take a note card and write God is dead on one side and sign their name on the back and hand it in. Only one student refused to do that so he was challenged to convert or convince some group of folks that God is real or he would lose credit or get a bad score, or something like that. The article went on to describe how unrealistic that was and that a professor who did something like that would be fired in real life. I gave Kara the article and told her to read it which she did.
When she got home I asked her what she thought of the movie and the first thing she said was that is was very biased. Her and her friend were also very disappointed about what happened to the atheist professor at the end. Over all she thought the movie was poor quality except for the guy who played the professor, she said he was a good actor. My response, well, it’s Hercules and the captain of Andromeda, of course he’s a great actor! I think Kevin Sorbo is a fun actor and I would love to work with him on a film, or for that matter just about anyone on a film. I just want to work on or in a film period!!! But really, he does seem fun to an extent. I Liked his official FaceBook page a while back and thought at first it must not be him who was running the thing. It would have the oddest not so good posts from time to time. But then it would have stuff that seemed like it could really be him after all. After a while I realized the issue. It was him and he basically a Conservative Republican Christian and often posts what I feel are mean conservative posts. Seriously not cool stuff sometimes. So, when I heard he was staring in the new religious film, God’s Not Dead, I was not the least bit surprised. In other words, I do not want to marry Kevin Sorbo! I’ll continue saving myself for Bill Nye.
About what the article said about how a professor wouldn’t really get away with that sort of thing in real life, I had to think about that one a bit. I was brought up in a world that taught that Christians were, are and will be persecuted for their faith. Stories went around about teachers trying to ruin childrens faith. They would tell how there was a movement of atheist who would ask kindergarteners, “how do you know there’s a God?” And how that one question would set up serious doubt from the devil in those poor childrens minds. Did that really happen? I have no personal experience that it did but it could have, I don’t know. There was and still is schools who have hired angry atheist as well as angry Christians set on influencing people but many schools now are more careful of going against what a child’s parent teaches them no matter what the belief.
My sister had an interesting teacher in 9th grade. He did actually put the, “how do you know there’s a God” challenge to her. But, like I said, she was in 9th grade, not kindergarten. People by that age should be challenge and should know why they believe what they believe. Her answer was a challenge back, “How do you know there is wind? You can’t see it. But, you can feel it and you can see the results of it.” She explained that it was the same with God, she could feel him, she could see the results of him. Before the teacher had put this challenge to her he had grown accustom to her constantly challenging him. She told us he taught every religion like it was his own but when it came to Christianity and Judaism he basically slaughtered them. She made a point to challenge him as often as she could. She felt it wasn’t just for her, or even him, but for the other students as well. They needed a good example and to see that his view point was flawed.
My folks and I saw her as a hero. No one else was challenging him. Of course my view point was biased at that time. She was my big sister, my folks had conditioned us well, Christianity was obviously the only correct way. Anyone who disagreed was wrong and in need of salvation. Period! And the Bible said we would be persecuted for Christs sake so it was an honor for her to be persecuted.
But, was she really being persecuted? If you are looking to be persecuted you will see anything negative as your persecution. In other words you will make it happen. By the time he challenged her belief in God he had already been through the ringer of her circular thinking. We didn’t know that’s what we were doing, we were masters of it unknowingly. She saw his exasperation, his action to quit challenging her, as a victory for Christ when in actuality it was more likely he was exasperated at her never being able to prove a point with out going back to the circle and never really answering clearly and scientifically. A belief based on religion isn’t meant to be proven scientifically because it is important that it be taken by faith. So explaining it will always end up going in circles. If one is happy and satisfied with that then good for them. But, they should not be so hard headed that they insist others join their circular reasoning and consider them selves persecuted when they don’t or are challenged. One really shouldn’t set out to prove it either. One should just accept it or don’t. It’s not about proof and science, it’s about faith. Other people have their faith as well. It’s crazy to try to convert them to ones unprovable faith, one should just respect it. After all one has first hand experience believing something that can not be proved. Where’s the empathy folks? !
The famous debate between Bill Nye and Ken Ham is a perfect example for such circular reasoning issues. When Bill didn’t know the answer to something he would admit it openly without shame. When Ken was so challenged he would revert to, “There’s this book…” Meaning “it says so in the Bible so therefor it is true”. How can you have a real discussion or debate with someone who keeps coming back to the same sentence about it being in “this book” rather then answering the question with facts or a simple “I don’t know”. What about the other books? They say thing quite different then the Bible and many of them were also “divinely” written. Ken Ham showed his expertise in circular reasoning. He laid out a map of what not to do. However, there are many Christians and Creationist who are celebrating his victory and celebrating their persecution cause that’s how they are programmed to see it. I know, I used to be one.
I got this brilliant idea regarding the movie as well as other Christian flicks. Kara’s recently watched the Mel Brooks films, Robin Hood: Men In Tights and High Anxiety. Her sister threw a fit when she tried to play Spaceballs…again. So between all the Mel Brooks time and the religious film I came up with a great idea for a fun satire, parody type film. It would be one that has really mean Atheist that have scowls and never smile unless it’s an evil smile and kind of bent over hench man looking and the Christians have a soft halo type glow behind their heads with perfect posture and do ridiculously kind things constantly but then when no one is looking they send evil threats through the computer to the Atheist. Of course every type of person that isn’t a Christmas would be overly stereo typed. It could be a lot of fun. I haven’t got a plot but maybe one day I will or someone else will do it. If anyone gets a successful idea from this I insist you cast me. If you don’t the Flying Spaghetti Monster will no longer allow you to eat pasta.
Read Full Post »